Welcome to Andy's Sushi Bar
Andy's Sushi Bar, nestled within Wholey's at 1711 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, is a beloved destination for sushi enthusiasts. With over 30 years of experience, Andy crafts each dish with meticulous care, showcasing exceptional quality and creativity. Patrons rave about the melt-in-your-mouth freshness of the fish and unique rolls, like the special mango roll, which strikes a perfect balance of flavors. The charming atmosphere, complemented by Andy's warm personality and engaging storytelling, makes every visit memorable. Recommended as a hidden gem, Andy's Sushi Bar promises delightful culinary experiences that celebrate the art of sushi.
Andy's Sushi Bar: Reviews & Ratings
Best sushi in the city by far. Andy is so nice and funny with excellent customer service. He had some extra eel and made me a nigiri piece as a sample while waiting for my rolls. So so delicious .
What an absolute treat to be able to visit such a well-loved establishment. Andy has a little stand inside of Wholey's, then you can eat in the dining room upstairs. I got the special mango roll, and WOW. It was incredible. The quality of fish, the craftsmanship, the love put into it, everything is just so special. I would highly recommend coming by and meeting Andy, you won't regret it.
Andy's sushi is top notch! Andy has been doing this for over 30 years and it truly shows in the quality of his creations. Not only is he a master of his sushi craft, he's also a hoot! I always enjoy getting sushi from him and having a chat. My first day back from vacation and dad dad made me go straight to Wholey's to get Andi's sushi. We both love it!!
Andy is friendly and it’s neat to watch him work. He announces some of the ingredients as he places them and I enjoyed interacting with him while he made my sushi order. The sushi was amazing—the special Andy roll was great, the salmon mango roll was interesting—he also puts shiso in it and it’s a great flavor that I’ve never had before in sushi. It’s a quirky and neat location, and I will be back!
I went to Andy’s Sushi at Wholey’s for the first time yesterday and I’m already planning my next visit. Everything was incredibly fresh—like, melt-in-your-mouth fresh. You can tell Andy takes real pride in his craft. The rolls were beautifully prepared, the flavors were clean and balanced, and the service was fast and friendly. This spot is a hidden gem inside the market, and absolutely worth seeking out. Highly recommend if you’re a sushi lover or just looking for a high-quality lunch in the Strip.
Had the good fortune to order a few sushi dishes from Andy. Although he had just gotten to his booth, he was in good humor and energetic. He set to work without complaint and was impressive to watch. He was a great showman with astonishing knife skills. The price for the volume and quality of sushi is hard to beat. Highly recommended.
I have traveled all around and have tried the top sushi places. Andy's is one, if not, the best sushi I have tried. If there were more stars to give I would. Andy is a delight to talk with and the sushi is the most fresh and amazing experience. This is located in a fish market and there is no restaurant. When we ordered Andy wanted to talk with us and made us exactly what we wanted. We brought the order upstairs to random cafeteria tables with butcher paper easy clean up. Despite this not having some high end restaurant atmosphere, the quality of the sushi made up for it alone. Andy came and talked with us for a minute and is just a great guy. I am going back for dates with my girlfriend, when friends come in from out of town and just when I want the most high quality fantastic sushi! Thank you Andy!
CASH only! Sushi was tasty. I’m not sushi expert but tried many places and this is one of the bests if you don't mind its super casual settings. It’s inside the seafood store so I would not recommend if someone is sensitive to fish smell, etc. There is a dining room upstairs to take the food there and eat :)
Location
-
1711 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States Hotline: +1 412-281-8272
Welcome to Andy's Sushi Bar, a culinary gem nestled within Wholey's Market in the heart of Pittsburgh. Located at 1711 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, Andy’s Sushi Bar offers a delightful fusion of quality, craftsmanship, and warm hospitality. For over three decades, Andy has dedicated himself to the art of sushi making, earning a well-deserved reputation as a master of his craft.
As you step into this cozy nook, you’ll be greeted by Andy himself, whose friendly demeanor and quick wit create an inviting atmosphere. Many patrons highlight their experiences with him, noting his exceptional customer service and the personal touch he brings to each order. A visit here often evolves into a delightful interaction, making your meal enjoyable beyond just the sushi.
But it’s the sushi that truly shines at Andy’s. Each roll is a testament to the quality of ingredients and the careful preparation that goes into it. Customers rave about the freshness of the fish—each bite is described as "melt-in-your-mouth". The acclaimed special mango roll, for instance, has left many in awe, showcasing Andy's ability to elevate classic sushi through innovative flavors and presentation.
Andy's commitment to excellence is evident in his creations; whether it's the unique salmon mango roll adorned with shiso or the artisanally crafted special Andy roll, each dish is bursting with flavors that are clean, balanced, and beautifully presented. The atmosphere is further enhanced by the unique setting of Wholey's, where the hustle of the market surrounds the intimate experience of dining on expertly prepared sushi.
For sushi lovers and adventurous eaters alike, Andy's Sushi Bar is a must-visit destination in Pittsburgh. Whether you choose to dine while watching Andy skillfully prepare your meal or take a delicious roll to go, rest assured that you’ll be indulging in some of the best sushi the city has to offer. Be sure to make it a point to meet Andy—you won’t regret it!
Contact: +1 412-281-8272